NEW: Heap for mobile. Track every interaction, on every platform.

Learn more
skip to content
Loading...
    • The Digital Insights Platform Transform your digital experience
    • How Heap Works A video guide
    • How Heap Compares Heap vs. competitors
    • The Future of Insights A comic book guide
  • Data Insights

    • Session Replay Complete context with a single click
    • Illuminate Data science that pinpoints unknown friction
    • Journeys Visual maps of all user flows

    Data Analysis

    • Segments User cohorts for actionable insights
    • Dashboards Share insights on critical metrics
    • Charts Analyze everything about your users
    • Playbooks Plug-and-play templates and analyses

    Data Foundation

    • Capture Automatic event tracking and apis
    • Mobile Track and analyze your users across devices
    • Enrichment Add context to your data
    • Integrations Connect bi-directionally to other tools

    Data Management

    • Governance Keep data clean and trusted
    • Security & Privacy Security and compliance made simple
    • Infrastructure How we build for scale
    • Heap Connect Send Heap data directly to your warehouse
  • Solutions

    • Funnel Optimization Improve conversion in user flows
    • Product Adoption Maximize adoption across your site
    • User Behavior Understand what your users do
    • Product Led Growth Manage PLG with data

    Industries

    • SaaS Easily improve acquisition, retention, and expansion
    • eCommerce Increase purchases and order value
    • Financial Services Raise share of wallet and LTV

    Heap For Teams

    • Product Teams Optimize product activation, conversion and retention
    • Marketing Teams Optimize acquisition performance and costs
    • Data Teams Optimize behavioral data without code
  • Pricing
  • Support

    • Heap University Video Tutorials
    • Help Center How to use Heap
    • Heap Plays Tactical how-to guides
    • Heap Updates
    • Professional Services

    Resources

    • Blog A community for digital builders
    • Content Library Ebooks, whitepapers, videos, guides
    • Press News from and about Heap
    • Webinars & Events Virtual and live events
    • Careers Join us

    Ecosystem

    • Customer Community Join the conversation
    • Partners Technology and Solutions Partners
    • Developers
    • Customers Over 8,000 successful companies
  • Free TrialRequest Demo
  • Log In
  • Free Trial
  • Request Demo
  • Log In

All Blogs

Data Stories

How to Lie with Data Visualization

Ravi Parikh
April 14, 20143 min read
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
Heap

Data visualization is one of the most important tools we have to analyze data. But it’s just as easy to mislead as it is to educate using charts and graphs. In this article we’ll take a look at three of the most common ways in which visualizations can be misleading.

Truncated Y-Axis

One of the easiest ways to misrepresent your data is by messing with the y-axis of a bar graph, line graph, or scatter plot. In most cases, the y-axis ranges from 0 to a maximum value that encompasses the range of the data. However, sometimes we change the range to better highlight the differences. Taken to an extreme, this technique can make differences in data seem much larger than they are.

Let’s see how this works in practice. The two graphs below show the exact same data, but use different scales for the y-axis:

Graph with a misleading y-axis

Two graphs that show the same data but a different y-axis.

Misleading y-axis

On the left, we’ve constrained the y-axis to range from 3.140% to 3.154%. Doing so makes it look like interest rates are skyrocketing! At a glance, the bar sizes imply that rates in 2012 are several times higher than those in 2008. But displaying the data with a zero-baseline y-axis tells a more accurate picture, where interest rates are staying static.

If this example seems exaggerated, here are some real-world examples of truncated y-axes:

Misleading graph shows top tax rate

Misleading graph shows top tax rate

If Bush Tax Cuts Expire - Misleading Y-Axis

Misleading graph shows knuckleball velocity in baseball

Misleading graph shows knuckleball velocity in baseball

Misleading baseball graph

Cumulative graphs

Many people opt to create cumulative graphs of things like number of users, revenue, downloads, or other important metrics. For example, instead of showing a graph of our quarterly revenue, we might choose to display a running total of revenue earned to date. Let’s see how this might look:

Graph that shows cumulative annual revenue

Graph that shows cumulative annual revenue

Misleading cumulative annual revenue graph

We can’t tell much from this graph. It’s moving up and to the right, so things must be going well! But the non-cumulative graph paints a different picture:

Graph that shows non-cumulative annual revenue

Graph that shows non-cumulative annual revenue

Misleading non-cumulative annual revenue graph

Now things are a lot clearer. Revenues have been declining for the past ten years! If we scrutinize the cumulative graph, it’s possible to tell that the slope is decreasing as time goes on, indicating shrinking revenue. However, it’s not immediately obvious, and the graph is incredibly misleading.

There are lots of real-world cases of cumulative graphs that make things seem a lot more positive than they are. A prominent example is Apple’s usage of a cumulative graph to show iPhone sales.

Ignoring conventions

One of the most insidious tactics people use in constructing misleading data visualizations is to violate standard practices. We’re used to the fact that pie charts represent parts of a whole or that timelines progress from left to right. So when those rules get violated, we have a difficult time seeing what’s actually going on. We’re wired to misinterpret the data, due to our reliance on these conventions.

Here’s an example of a pie chart that Fox Chicago aired during the 2012 primaries:

Pie chart that shows 2012 presidential run results

Pie chart that shows 2012 presidential run results

2021 Presidential Results Misleading Pie Chart

The three slices of the pie don’t add up to 100%. The survey presumably allowed for multiple responses, in which case a bar chart would be more appropriate. Instead, we get the impression that each of the three candidates have about a third of the support, which isn’t the case.

Another example is this visualization published by Business Insider, which seems to show the opposite of what’s really going on:

Chart that shows the number of gun deaths in Florida

Chart that shows the number of gun deaths in Florida

Misleading graph showing gun deaths in Florida

At first glance, it looks like gun deaths are on the decline in Florida. But a closer look shows that the y-axis is upside-down, with zero at the top and the maximum value at the bottom. As gun deaths increase, the line slopes downward, violating a well established convention that y-values increase as we move up the page.

There’s a simple takeaway from all this: be careful when designing visualizations, and be extra careful when interpreting graphs created by others. We’ve covered three common techniques, but it’s just the surface of how people use data visualization to mislead.Additional resources:

  • What is product analytics?

  • Google analytics alternatives

Ravi Parikh

Was this helpful?
PreviousNext

Related Stories

See All

  • Google Analytics 4

    Product Insights

    Google Analytics 4: What it promises, and what that really means

    April 28, 2022

  • Heap.io

    How to

    The 3 key first steps to improving CRO

    March 29, 2023

  • Heap.io

    Data Stories

    Celebrating H&R Block as the inaugural winner of the Digital Innovator Award

    March 22, 2023

Subscribe

Sign up to stay on top of the latest posts.

Better insights. Faster.

Request Demo
  • Platform
  • Capture
  • Enrichment
  • Integrations
  • Governance
  • Security & Privacy
  • Infrastructure
  • Illuminate
  • Segments
  • Charts
  • Dashboards
  • Playbooks
  • Use Cases
  • Funnel Optimization
  • Product Adoption
  • User Behavior
  • Product Led Growth
  • Customer 360
  • SaaS
  • eCommerce
  • Financial Services
  • Why Heap
  • The Digital Insights Platform
  • How Heap Works
  • How Heap Compares
  • The Future of Insights
  • Resources
  • Blog
  • Content Library
  • Events
  • Topics
  • Heap University
  • Community
  • Professional Services
  • Company
  • About
  • Partners
  • Press
  • Careers
  • Customers
  • Support
  • Request Demo
  • Help Center
  • Contact Us
  • Pricing
  • Social
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

© 2023 Heap Inc. All Rights Reserved.

  • Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Status
  • Trust